The classic décor and charming ambiance made me feel nostalgic. The staff was incredibly accommodating, ensuring easy access throughout the hotel, which I truly appreciated as a senior visitor. Hamlet, the resident cat, added a delightful touch.

More variety in dining options would be beneficial.

The location is perfect for exploring the city, with easy access to the subway and key attractions. The suite was charming and spacious for three people. Housekeeping was prompt and kind, adding to the overall positive experience during our stay.

The cold shower issue was disappointing.

would come back for sure

Location was perfect for exploring the city. Our queen room had air conditioning, a flat-screen TV, and a private bathroom with free toiletries. Staff were friendly and the lobby offered free coffee. Awesome that they had complimentary bottled water. Fitness centre was available for workouts too, which was a plus!

The location is perfect for exploring the city. We enjoyed complimentary tickets to Big Bus tours. Our suite was charming and spacious for three people—all a plus!

The Algonquin is a charming historical hotel with a fantastic location near Broadway. Rooms are compact but well-kept, and the staff is incredibly friendly. However, the resort fee felt a bit unnecessary, and the noise from the street was noticeable. Overall, a lovely place with character.

great location, but some room concerns

The location is truly unbeatable, just a short walk to the Broadway theaters. The front doormen provided exceptional service, always welcoming us with a smile and offering assistance whenever needed.

Some aspects of the room did not meet expectations for quality.

I had a good stay at the Algonquin, captivated by its charm and historic ambiance. The staff's warm hospitality. I did find the dining options a bit limited, but the drinks at the bar were enjoyable. A lovely experience!

The attentive staff remembered my preferences after just one visit.

I was disappointed that the coffee machine in the lobby was broken.

We had an awesome getaway with friends! Conveniently located near Times Square and Radio City Music Hall, we loved exploring the area. The hotel had this unique charm. Hamlet the cat was a fun surprise. The breakfast was tasty, but the choices were a bit limited. Can't wait to come back!

We had some issues with billing during checkout. It took a while to get through to someone to resolve it, which was frustrating. Make sure to double-check your charges before leaving.

Can recommend for a fleeting pause

Comfortable bed, clean room, with a great shower and thoughtful staff who quickly helped me with check-in even late at night after arriving from the airport 15 km away.

The room was spacious but staff interactions were lacking warmth.

I loved the delicious breakfast with excellent coffee and the charming atmosphere that allowed me to feel the historical essence of the building. would definitely choose this spot again for a special occasion.

The unique ambiance of the lobby stands out, exuding old-world charm with its stunning decor. The bar area is a cool spot drenched in vibrant blue, perfect for an evening drink and light fare, providing a glimpse of the hotel's storied past.

The restaurant and bar prices are nearly jaw-dropping, feeling almost like a Jedi mind trick. Limited bistro menu doesn't offer much for variety, and the absence of complimentary food for morning coffee left me a bit dry. The ice machine being down was a hassle, and I was surprised to learn that the iconic New York Times delivery to rooms was discontinued. The atmosphere felt less like a literary haven, more like a tired relic—not what I'd hoped for during my stay.

Historic hotel with great atmosphere and friendly staff. Small rooms feel cramped for the price. Enjoyed the location, perfect for walking tours. Bar prices are high for what you get.